Jose Mourinho and Pep Guardiola are already making
What have Jose Mourinho
and Pep Guardiola changed so far?
By Peter Smith
Last Updated: 16/08/16
9:10pm
Jose Mourinho and Pep Guardiola are already
making big changes
Manchester United and
Manchester City have made big changes this summer. Sky Sports has once again
teamed up with Hewlett Packard Enterprises (HPE) to look at how the two teams
did on the opening weekend of the new season – and how their tactics and style
changed from the final fixture of 2015/16.
Manchester United
Manchester United beat
Bournemouth 3-1 at Old Trafford in their final Premier League fixture last
season and they repeated that scoreline on the opening weekend of the new
campaign at the Vitality Stadium - but there's been plenty of change both on
and off the pitch between those two games.
Analysis
that gives insight, understanding and opinion across major sporting moments.
Find out more.
In the dugout, Jose
Mourinho has replaced Louis van Gaal and the Portuguese has made significant
changes on the field. New signings have taken up key positions and there was
also a change in formation and approach for his first Premier League in charge
of United.
In Van Gaal's Old
Trafford farewell - a game postponed after a bomb scare - United cruised to
victory against Eddie Howe's men, with Wayne Rooney playing a key role in the
creation of two of the home side's goals as well as finding the net himself in
a man-of-the-match performance.
Van Gaal fielded a
4-1-4-1 formation back in May, with Michael Carrick sitting behind a midfield
four of Juan Mata, Jesse Lingard, Rooney and Anthony Martial, with breakthrough
star Marcus Rashford leading the line.
Rashford's place in the
starting line-up was taken by United's new superstar striker Zlatan Ibrahimovic
on Sunday, while Mourinho also opted for a midfield pair of Ander Herrera and
Marouane Fellaini (with £89m buy Paul Pogba suspended) behind an attacking trio
of Rooney, Martial and Mata.
The new boss also made
changes to the defence, with new signing Eric Bailly and Luke Shaw stepping
into the back-line in place of the suspended Chris Smalling and youngster
Cameron Borthwick-Jackson.
Manchester United's average positions on the
final day of 2015/16
There were always going
to be clear differences in United's style for an opening-weekend away game
compared to an end-of-season dead rubber at home and the contrast in their
approach was marked.
United played far deeper
at the weekend compared to May - just three of their players had
an average position in the Bournemouth half, compared with eight at the
end of last season. This could be indicative of Mourinho's long-held preference
for a low-block when defending.
United's average possession-winning line on the
final day of 2015/16
United's average possession-winning line on the
first day of 2016/17
Indeed, the average
distance from United's goal at which they won back possession from their
opponents shifted 12 metres further back. They also played 52 more passes in
their own half and 169 fewer in Bournemouth's.
Other notable
differences between Van Gaal's final Premier League United side and Mourinho's
first was a significant drop-off in possession (66.3 per cent to 52.6 per cent)
and fewer passes (677 to 560), which perhaps hints the current United XI have
been instructed to play in a more direct manner. But the significant increase
in clearances and tackles made by the visitors on the south coast highlights
the improved performance from Bournemouth.
United's attack zones on the first day of
2016/17
United's three goals
came in a different fashion to those they scored against Bournemouth at Old
Trafford. In May, United spent long periods camped around the Cherries' box,
and eventually unlocked their defence with neat passing moves. On Sunday, Mata
capitalised on a poor back-pass, Rooney pounced on a Martial mis-hit shot and
Ibrahimovic fired in a long-range drive.
So is this a sign of
things to come? It's too early to tell. Henrikh Mkhitaryan came on as a second
half sub and Pogba will almost certainly be involved on Friday night - two
players who will have a significant influence on United's play - while home
advantage and the context of the two matches cannot be overlooked.
But the Mourinho era is
underway with a victory - and the hope at Old Trafford is it will prove more
successful than his predecessor's.
Manchester City
A narrow 2-1 home win
over Sunderland - thanks to an 87th-minute own goal - is probably not how
Manchester City fans imagined their first game of the Pep Guardiola era going
but the Spaniard is off to a winning start and, just one game into his reign,
there are already notable differences from the methods of his predecessor
Manuel Pellegrini.
The Chilean drew his
final game in charge on the last weekend of the 2015/16 season 1-1 at Swansea
to all-but guarantee City a top-four finish. The visitors dominated the fixture
and should have won comfortably but in the end the team did what they had to do
to achieve the bare minimum in terms of their league ambitions: Champions
League qualification.
Sights are set far
higher this term and Guardiola has spent heavily in the summer transfer window
to bring about change. John Stones, now the world's most expensive defender
after his £50m move from Everton, and £13.8m purchase Nolito both went straight
into City's starting line-up on Saturday but it was changes to established
personnel which made the headlines.
Joe Hart, criticised by
Guardiola for his distribution, was replaced in goal by Willy Caballero, while,
alongside Stones, left-back Aleksandar Kolarov was preferred to Nicolas
Otamendi (who was carrying a knock) and Eliaquim Mangala.
Fernando, Kelechi Iheanacho
and Jesus Navas were also replaced from the starting XI which closed
Pellegrini's era, with David Silva, Raheem Sterling and Nolito stepping in.
City's attack locations on the final day of
2015/16
City's attack locations on the first day of
2016/17
It was Sterling who made
an immediate impact, winning a penalty inside five minutes for Sergio Aguero to
convert, and, after a Stones error had allowed Jermain Defoe to equalise, Navas
- whom Guardiola had turned to just before the hour mark - fizzed in a cross
which led to Paddy McNair's own goal.
Aguero had also played a
part in the early City goal at Swansea, with his blocked shot being tucked in
by Iheanacho, but despite the Manchester club being the better side in both
games, there was a clear change in style under the new manager.
City's average possession-winning line on final
day of 2015/16
City's average possession-winning line on the
first day of 2016/17
Unlike in south Wales,
City dominated possession on Saturday, controlling the ball 76.9 per cent of
the time, compared to the 50-50 split in Swansea. While City unleashed a
similar number of shots across the two matches, the total number and accuracy
of passes increased in Guardiola's first game.
City didn't just control
the game better against Sunderland, they did so in a more attacking way, higher
up the field. They won back possession five metres further up the pitch on
average, had six players spend the majority of the game in the visitors' half
and made 128 more passes in the Black Cats' portion of the pitch.
City's average positions on the final day of
2015/16
City's average positions on the first day of
2016/17
The average position graphic
also highlights some interesting tactical moves by Guardiola, with the
full-backs playing further forward and more tucked in than they did at Swansea,
and central midfielder Fernandinho splitting the centre-backs, who pushed up
the field.
Two games where City had
the upper hand, one drawn, one won. Only time will tell whether the changes by
Guardiola prove to be as effective throughout the course of the season.
Comments
Post a Comment